Goblin Boss Critical Hits Hot Sauce Sampler: Best-Seller 4-Pack Gift Set

Some sauces land every single time. The Critical Hits sampler collects the four Goblin Boss hot sauces our customers reach for again and again, our best sellers, in one gift-ready box. The heat climbs from mild to hot, with sweet, smoky, earthy and fruity flavors along the way, all made in small batches with real fruit, vegetables and peppers. It’s the easiest way to try the sauces that made our name, and a hot sauce gift set any D&D player, Game Master or flavor chaser will be glad to unbox.

Meet Your Party

Cleric’s Pineapple Blessing (Mild)
Sweet pineapple and honey with a gentle serrano glow, finished with garlic and cumin. The party’s healer and the perfect place to start, even for people who don’t usually like hot sauce.
Try it on: eggs and breakfast, fish tacos, chicken and wings, pizza

Goblin Boss Gobblin’ Sauce (Medium)
⭐ Our most-reviewed sauce
Straight from the Goblin Boss’s own cauldron: red serrano and smoky chipotle with tomato, garlic, a splash of lime and a hint of cumin. Bold, savory and endlessly versatile. One taste and you’ll be gobblin’ for more.
Try it on: tacos and burritos, pizza, eggs, kobold toes

Ranger’s Menacing Mushroom (+1 Medium)
Smoked red jalapeños and mushroom with carrot, tomato and garden vegetables, sweetened with honey and seasoned with thyme and smoked paprika. It stalks you with deep, smoky, savory flavor, then lands a steady, well-aimed hit of heat.
Try it on: burgers and steaks, eggs and breakfast hash, pizza and pasta, roasted vegetables, Bloody Marys

Wizard’s Enchanted Cherry Blaze (Hot)
🏆 Voted “Best All-Around Sauce” at the 2026 Detroit Hot Sauce Fest
Tart cherries and fiery habanero, rounded out with maple syrup, cocoa and a hint of cinnamon. Sweet, deep and properly hot.
Try it on: eggs, beef, wings, chili, and yes, ice cream

Why Adventurers Love It

• Our four best sellers in one box. These are the sauces customers reorder most, so every bottle is a crowd-pleaser.
• Big flavor, approachable heat. It runs from mild to hot with no extreme-heat bottle, so most heat tolerances can enjoy all four.
• A gift-ready window box with fantasy, tabletop-inspired labels. It’s great for game night, birthdays, the holidays, and stocking stuffers.
• Find your favorite, then upgrade. Every sauce in the sampler also comes in a full 5 oz bottle.

What’s in the Box

Four 2 fl oz bottles (8 fl oz / 236 mL total):

• Cleric’s Pineapple Blessing: pineapple, apple cider vinegar, honey, serrano pepper, onion, garlic, salt, cumin
• Goblin Boss Gobblin’ Sauce: distilled white vinegar, red serrano pepper, tomato, chipotle pepper, onion, garlic scapes, salt, cilantro, lime juice, cumin, black pepper
• Ranger’s Menacing Mushroom: white vinegar, smoked red jalapeños, tomato, bell pepper, carrot, onion, honey, mushroom, salt, garlic, thyme, smoked paprika, celery seed
• Wizard’s Enchanted Cherry Blaze: tart cherries, white vinegar, habaneros, maple syrup, onion, salt, cocoa powder, cinnamon